There are many deconstructing Christians that want to eliminate Paul. Likewise, there are many liberal scholars that believe that Paul actually did highjack the Jesus movement and make his own form of Christianity. You can find many articles that state unequivocally that one cannot harmonize the teachings of Jesus with those of Paul. Thus, the question of this title; Did Paul hijack the Jesus movement, or was he a mystic?
So, let’s first look at the idea that he hijacked
Christianity. Is that plausible? We must look at what we know about Paul. He
was a Roman citizen from the town of Tarsus. It was a wealthy city that was a
major trade location. It was expensive to live there. Paul was a Pharisee and a
rabbi. He was a student of Gamaliel, who was a student of the great Hillel. He
was given a letter of recommendation by the Sanhedrin that granted him the authority
hunt down and kill Jesus followers. He was a tent maker which made him a
skilled craftsman. When you look at Paul and his life, what could make him want
to hijack Christianity? It is obvious to me that the only possible thing that
could make the apostle Paul give up all of the above would be a radical
mystical encounter!
Paul explains what that radical mystical encounter was and I
will take him at his word. Act
9:1-“9
Meanwhile, Saul was still breathing out murderous threats against the Lord's
disciples. He went to the high priest (2) and asked him for letters
to the synagogues in Damascus, so that if he found any there who belonged to
the Way, whether men or women, he might take them as prisoners to Jerusalem.
(3) As he neared Damascus on his journey, suddenly a light from
heaven flashed around him. (4) He fell to the ground and heard a
voice say to him, "Saul, Saul, why do you persecute me?" (5)
"Who are you, Lord?" Saul asked. "I am Jesus, whom you are
persecuting," he replied. (6) "Now get up and go into the
city, and you will be told what you must do." (7) The men
traveling with Saul stood there speechless; they heard the sound but did not
see anyone. (8) Saul got up from the ground, but when he opened his
eyes he could see nothing. So they led him by the hand into Damascus. (9)
For three days he was blind, and did not eat or drink anything.”
This was the beginning of Paul’s mystical experience with the Cosmic Christ.
Why else would Paul choose a hard life of persecution
impending harm and death at every turn? The commonsense answer is that he
absolutely would not choose this without having had a remarkable unexplainable
experience with Jesus. So, what was the purpose? Paul explains that he was
called in this mystical experience to be the apostle to the Gentiles. This
meant that the Jesus movement was cosmic in nature. Jesus brought a message
that was universal directed to humanity in general, and not just to the first
century Jews. It was good news because everyone, Jew and Gentile alike was
reconciled to God through Jesus the Christ. He was the progenitor of a new
humanity. It was a humanity that would be recognized for their love for one
another. It was a humanity that had the Spirit of Christ given to all.
Yes, and Paul the mystic was the one entrusted with defining
what the fruit of that Spirit would be. It was Paul the mystic that was given
the definition of love. It was Paul the mystic that was told that God was in Christ
reconciling the world to himself, and that all were reconciled. It was Paul
that was given the message of reconciliation which was to merely proclaim that
all were reconciled and therefore, each could and should be reconciled and
accept that as a fact.
No, it was not Paul that hijacked the Jesus movement. The
Jesus movement was hijacked by orthodoxy to provide power and control to the
church. It was hijacked by those who would unite the empire and church. It was given
the sword and more than that, the right to relegate some people to heavenly
bliss and some unfortunate people to eternal damnation. It was given a false
narrative and exterminated and burned gospels that were contemporary with the
gospels and epistles sanctioned by orthodoxy. They would have never come to
light except for the happenstance of finding the Nag Hamadi library in Egypt.
Even with that, much of the writing and oral tradition was suppressed.
I am not claiming that everything Paul wrote was mystical
revelation. That isn’t even the way that it works. Paul was a mystic, and Paul
was a first century Jewish rabbi and sometimes the rabbinical got the best of
the mystic, but the standard for measurement was in large part revealed to Paul
the mystic. When you want to know what was revealed and what was not, judge it
by the fruit of the Spirit and the definition of love. If it squares with those
two it is definitely revelation from the creative source God.